Vitamin Experts Condemn Harvard Study

Friday, January 16, 2009

Doctors and scientists say study was flawed

Today, the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH)—a nonprofit group of doctors, scientists, suppliers and consumers supporting the use of natural therapies—has released its critique of a major study that claims vitamins don't prevent cancer. The study by Dr Jennifer Lin and colleagues at the Harvard Medical School was published on January 7 in The Journal of the National Cancer Institute, The ANH's evaluation concludes that the lack of effects demonstrated could have been predicted before the start of the 8-year study involving over 7,600 women with heart disease or high risk of it who averaged 60 years of age.

"This study was destined from the outset to obtain a negative result" said Dr Damien Downing, medical director of ANH, a practicing medical doctor who has practiced nutritional and environmental medicine for over 25 years. Dr Downing also criticised the journal editor for publishing the study "in the knowledge that the data do not support the conclusions." Dr Robert Verkerk, scientific director of ANH, said: "Diet is the single biggest factor contributing to cancer, and there is a rapidly growing body of both research and clinical evidence to show that concentrated forms of nutrients including vitamins, minerals and botanicals are invaluable in cancer prevention." ANH's critique shows that the study has no bearing on the effects of the three vitamins used, vitamins C and E and beta-carotene, on cancer prevention in healthy people. "Many of the risk factors associated with heart disease and cancer are shared, and nearly 80% of the women in the study were overweight or obese, therefore, likely to have been much more susceptible to cancer than a non-diseased, healthy population. Some may even have been presymptomatic", adds Dr Verkerk.

The ANH expert group argues that the dosages and forms selected for the study did not equate with those that would be most likely to yield a positive result. "Most people who are keen to prevent cancer don't just take these three vitamins", said Dr Verkerk, "they take a whole range of vitamin, minerals and phytonutrients most of which have been independently verified to have powerful anti-cancer effects".

Dr Steve Hickey, another member of ANH's expert group, referred to the approach used by the Harvard team as "cookbook science". He said: "Certain researchers have hit on a cookbook recipe for performing studies, purporting to show that antioxidant vitamins are ineffective. In the most recent case, Jennifer Lin and colleagues make the erroneous claim that antioxidant vitamins do not prevent cancer". Gretchen DuBeau, executive director of the ANH's US affiliate, added: "It's unfortunate that the media has compounded this misinformation by incorrectly reporting the erroneous results as applicable to the general population."

Healthy Times Newspaper News and Press Releases

This article has been read 1888 times.

Would you like to own a Healthy Times Newspaper Franchise?

For more information about becoming a Healthy Times Newspaper Franchise owner, including a franchise overview, start-up costs, fees, training and more, please visit our Healthy Times Newspaper Franchise Information page.

Or complete our free franchise advise form for a consultation about Healthy Times Newspaper Franchise or any other franchise listed on The Franchise Mall.

Healthy Times Newspaper Logo

36764 Maximillian Avenue
Murrieta, CA

Phone: 951.461.3456

Healthy Times Newspaper Franchise Information

Share This Page!


First Name:
Last Name:
State: (US inquiries only please)
Capital to Invest

(Min $50k Investment)
Investment Timeframe:

Can I use my 401K or IRA
to buy a business?

Submit your request for a
FREE Franchise Consultation.